Security vs. Reconciliation: The Afghan Conundrum The New York Review of Books / By Ahmad Rashid / February 6, 2012 The following is taken from the author’s written briefing for the Munich... Read more
Winning Hearts and Minds? Examining the Relationship between Aid and Security in Afghanistan Feinstein International Center / By Paul Fishstein and Andrew Wilder / January 2012 This paper by Paul Fishstein and Andrew Wilder presents... Read more
Afghanistan’s Paramilitary Policing in Context. The Risks of Expediency Afghanistan Analysts Network(AAN) Despite representing the bulk of Afghanistan’s post-2001 policing, the paramilitary dimension of the Afg... Read more
Kabul's Stealth Attack on Human Rights New York Times / By PATRICIA GOSSMAN / December 26, 2011 Watershed moments in Afghanistan happen by stealth. Last weekend — the anniversary... Read more
The Battle for Schools: The Taleban and State Education Afghanistan Analysts Network (AAN) / By Antonio Giustozzi / December 13, 2011 This new AAN report by authors Antonio Giustozzi and Claudio ... Read more
The Past is Here to Stay: Listening to Afghan Voices on Justice and Reconciliation Afghanistan Analysts Network(AAN) / By Sari Kouvo /November 27, 2011 The abuses and violations suffered by Afghans during the conflicts a... Read more
Peace offerings: Theories of conflict resolution and their applicability to Afghanistan Afghanistan analysts Network (AAN) / January 28, 2011 Despite the recent deployments of more troops and greater military resources to Afgha... Read more
Afghanistan endgame: Body formed to pave way for Taliban talks The Express Tribune / January 28, 2011 akistan and Afghanistan have established a joint commission to work out modalities for direct negoti... Read more
Taliban 'receptive to overtures for peace' The Telegraph / By Duncan Gardham /January 28, 2011 The number of “expressions of interest from senior members of the insurgency” have “di... Read more
The Washington Afghan officials want to prol Post / January 26, 2011 Afghan justice and security officials want to adopt the U.S. practice of detaining suspected insurgents indefinitel... Read more

17 July 2011
Afghanistan_Awaiting_for_Justice.jpg
Statement of Afghanistan Watch on the International Criminal Justice Day   This year for the first time in world history, 17 July is celebrated as International Criminal Justice Day. The day More...
18 July 2010
Press-Release-Access-to-Information-Campaign---18-07-10-_English_-1.jpg
17 civil society actors, representing more than 200 civil society organisations, and several media organisations, unite before the approaching Kabul Conference to ask the Afghan Government to pass More...
10 December 2009
pic_0030.jpg
Statement of Afghanistan Watch on the 10th of December the Universal Human Rights Day and Victims Day in Afghanistan The 10th of December is the Universal Day of Human Rights and officially More...
05 April 2009
pic_0016.jpg
President Karzai has recently signed Qanon-e Ahwal-e Shakhsiah Ahl-e Tashaio’a, or the Law on Private Matters of the Shiites, a new legislation dealing with the private matters of the Shiite More...

Newsletter_34_English.jpg
Haqiqat 34 contains news from Afghan print media with following details: Peace and Reconciliation with the Taliban: Sayed Yusuf Reza Gilani, the More...
Newsletter_33_English.jpg
Haqiqat 33 contains news from Afghan print media with following details: Reconciliation and peace talks with the Taliban: The investigation into the More...

05 March 2012
AW_CSIS.jpg
KABUL, AFGHANISTAN. Diverging views and growing skepticism regarding the current situation of political settlement and governance in Afghanistan marked a lively roundtable hosted by the Center for More...
19 December 2011
ICC_Meeting_2011.jpg
Speech of Director of Afghanistan Watch for the 10th Session of Assembly of States Parties (ASP), United Nation Head Quarter, December 16, 2011-New York Distinguished members of the Assembly of More...
13 September 2011
Research-training-for-women.jpg
For increasing research capacities inside the country, a 10 day theoretical training program called” research training for women” was conducted by Afghanistan Watch in Kabul. The training was More...
02 June 2011
Mazar_Conference.JPG
The “Consultation Conference with Civil Society Organizations and Victims of Mazar –e Sharif 1377 Massacre” was the title of another conference conducted by Afghanistan Watch at the regional More...
26 May 2011
Kabul-Conference.jpg
The “Consultation Conference with Civil Society Organizations and Victims of February 10, 1993 Massacre in Afshar, Kabul” was the title of a conference conducted by Afghanistan Watch in its More...

An overview of the negotiation with the Taliban in 2010

By Jawad Naji

The year 2010 is perhaps, an important year in the new political system of Afghanistan. Besides the issues of security, corruption, elections and the exit plan of international forces, the most important discussion of 2010 proposed by the government of Afghanistan, was negotiation and reconciliation with the Taliban.

In the early days of Mr. Karzai’ government there was an international and political intention against the Taliban to oust them from the region. It seemed that the trend would continue and the return of Taliban was improbable. Now, there is no talk of defeating and removing the insurgents but they are assumed as the second party to be negotiated with. There were talks of government’s stance and direct and indirect contact through with the Taliban, particularly through the commission for strengthening peace, but after the London Conference the discussion of talks with the Taliban became official.

 

Important events:

London Conference:

The government of Hamid Karzai officially proposed the idea of reconciliation and peace with the Taliban at the London Conference in 2010. This was welcomed and supported by the international community.

Peace Jirga:

The peace Jirga was launched following the London Conference in Kabul. The government of Afghanistan invited about 1600 participants in this consultative peace meeting. Cabinet members, provincial governors, tribal elders, university professors, MPs and provincial council members were the participants of this meeting. The objective to launch this Jirga was to seek ways and propose solutions in order to reach peace in Afghanistan. However, it was later revealed that the government had already developed the plans and schemes of this Jirga. It was named as state Jirga than a public meeting. Many of government critics like Abdullah Abdullah and tribal leaders like Mohamad Mohaqiq and General Dostum were not present in this meeting. The declaration released by the participants of the Jirga demanded for the release of Taliban prisoners as a sign of goodwill and removal of some Taliban leaders from the UN’s black list.

Maldives Meeting:

On the occasion of holding the Peace Jirga, the news spread about the peace meeting in the Maldives’ Islands with the presence of Hekmatyar’s son-in-law, Taliban leaders and some MPs. This peace meeting was held and at the end a declaration was announced. Later, the President’s spokesperson said that the meetings held in the foreign recreation places will have no achievements and the government did not participate in those meetings. Meanwhile the Hezb e Islami led by Gulbadin Hekmatyar also rejected the meetings of Maldives and called the meeting as personal and for recreation purposes.

Kabul Conference:

Perhaps, the important issue discussed in this conference were related to talks with the Taliban. Although the speakers did not mention about the details of it, it was observed that there had been talks on it behind the scene. Richard Holbrooke, former US special envoy to Afghanistan and Pakistan had said that in Kabul conference the major focus will be on the return of Taliban to their normal lives. In Kabul conference the government of Afghanistan financial aid to bring back the insurgents to the normal lives through and secondly they demanded to remove the names of ten Taliban commanders from the UN black list.

Removal from Blacklist:

The names of some Taliban leaders were eliminated from the UN black list based on a request from the Afghan government. This issue was proposed by the Afghan government to UN officials. From 45 people whose names were removed from black-list, 10 were Taliban members. UN called it as an outcome of success in the peace process.

Formation of High Council for Peace:

The president himself initiated and formed the high council for peace. A number of jihadi leaders were also present in the meeting held in this regard in the presidential palace. This council has 68 members and many of them were the mujahedeen commanders in the past. In relation to this council, there are local councils formed in some provinces. Mediation and contacts with the insurgents are supposed to be carried out by this council. It is worth noting that Wakil Ahmad Motawakil and Abdul Salam Zaef, two former Taliban leaders, have repeatedly rejected Karzai’s invitation to participate in this council.

Release of prisoners:

a considerable number of Taliban leaders are released from the prisoners as a sign of good will by the afghan government. At least, 172 Taliban leaders were released from prisoners under different pretext. It is said that their criminal cases are not processed but they are released.

Karzai’s meeting with a fake Taliban leader:

The media in recent days reported that Karzai met a fake Taliban leader in the presidential palace. The government believed he was second man in Taliban leadership and held talks with him. It is said that the person took away millions of dollars with him. The media reported that he was a shopkeeper in Quetta Pakistan. In 2010 the government focused more on the process of negotiation and talks with the Taliban. The statistic shows that 2010 has been the most deadly year for Afghan and foreign forces. Meanwhile, the Karzai administration had put all their efforts to bring the insurgents to peace process. Experts believe that all the efforts by the government is one sided and the response by the Taliban, not only show their lack of trust for reconciliation and talks but also providing such privileges for this group has encouraged them to fight more against the afghan government. It seems that discussing the issue of reconciliation with the Taliban in the media and public have strengthened the spirit of the Taliban and they want to use this opportunity to exert more pressure on the government of Afghanistan to gain more privileges. The process of talks and reconciliation with the Taliban is not new. During past years the Commission for Strengthening Peace led by Sibghatullah Mojaddadi also spent a huge amount of money and this time, again, a lot of money is spent in this regard, but there are serious concerns about the lack of transparency in this process and its outcomes.

Share
 

Based in Kabul, the Afghanistan Watch focuses on activities that promote justice, respect for human rights and a culture of accountability and transparency in the country. Recognizing the need for greater understanding of the perils and opportunities facing Afghanistan today, the organization aims to conduct in-depth research and publish reports and papers on issues relevant to its goals and values independently or in partnership with other national and international organizations.

Sign up below if you wish to receive our publications and news about our programmes, events and other relevant developments.

Required *

Please fill Position Field!

Please fill Email Field!

 
Looking Back: An Afghanistan Watch Analysis of the Voting Patterns in the First Parliament

What lessons can be drawn from the first parliamentary cycle? What voting patterns and political alignments have developed in the parliament? What ideas, ideologies and powers have been at play when the parliament voted for the Mass Media Law, the National Reconciliation Charter or the Higher Education Law? These are some of the questions addressed in Afghanistan Watch’s report ‘The First Experience - Voting Patterns and Political Alignments in the Wolesi Jirga 2005-2010’. Sari Kouvo, AAN Co-Director, takes a closer look at the research conducted by Afghanistan Watch and funded by AAN

Read More


 
Asia Speech for General Debate

Speech of Jalil Benish for the Assembly of States Parties to the Rome Statute of the ICC

Distinguished members of the Assembly of States Parties of the ICC, Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen:

My name is Jalil Benish of Afghanistan Watch from Kabul, Afghanistan, speaking on behalf of my colleagues in the Coalition for the ICC- Asia-Pacific.

We are witnessing a definite trend towards accountability for the most serious crimes in the Asia Pacific – a region that has seen horrible atrocities being committed in the past and present and yet is one of the most underrepresented before the ICC. Of the six ratifications for 2011, three of them – the Philippines in Southeast Asia, Maldives in South Asia and Vanuatu in the Pacific – are in Asia-Pacific, bringing to a total of 17 the states parties to the ICC from the region. On this occasion, we would also like to commend the government of Malaysia for having completed the necessary steps within the domestic level for accession to the Rome Statute, and call on it promptly deposit its instrument of accession, thus bringing to 18 the total number of states parties in the region.

pdf Read More

Website link: Coalition for the International Criminal Court (CICC)


 
Afghans campaign amid warzone

Aljazeera

A report released this month by the Afghanistan Watch organisation and funded by the Afghan Analysts Network characterised parliament as being wracked by continual ethnic and sectarian fights, throwing obstacles in front of processes such as approving effective cabinet nominees.

The report quoted Kabir Ranjbar, a member of parliament, as saying that "the approaches based on ethnicity, language and religion have been a main point of the Wolesi Jirga’s weakness and the main factor for approval of the incapable and inefficient ministers. If the [members of parliament] had considered the national interests during the process of confidence voting for the cabinet nominees, the consequent confusions would have been prevented."

Read More


 
Impunity and Instability: An Unbroken Cycle

Middle East Institute Viewpoints: Afghanistan, 1979-2009: In the Grip of Conflict • www.mei.edu

By: Abdul Jalil Benish, director of Afghanistan Watch

Impunity in Afghanistan is like an unwritten law which benefits the wealthiest and most powerful criminals.

Read More


 
Relevance of the ICC in the Context of Afghanistan

Niamatullah Ibrahimi, Co-Founder of Afghanistan Watch writes on The Relevance of the ICC in the Context of Afghanistan in the ICC Monitor, the Journal of the Coalition of the International Criminal Court

The relevance of the ICC has been keenly felt in Afghanistan since 2001. During this period, human rights violations have continued unabated, a culture of impunity and lack of accountability has been further entrenched, and the Afghan state has displayed a chronic lack of commitment to hold accountable those responsible for heinous crimes and massive human rights abuses.

Read More